Why is world cocoa getting cheaper when Ivory Coast shipments are down by half?
Filed By irfolks
Economics Desk2 min read
Cocoa on the New York exchange fell 4.86% in a day to US$4,871 a ton at the 10 November close, the lowest since June. At the same time, farmers in Ivory Coast delivered only 55,317 tons of beans to ports in the week ending 8 November, about half of the 107,139 tons a year earlier. Supply is thin, yet the price is dropping. How come?
Two forces are pulling in opposite directions. Stocks in ICE exchange warehouses rose to 3.75 million bags, the highest in about 2.5 years, and analysts such as Commerzbank see the drop as driven more by weaker chocolate demand than by supply, according to Reku citing several sources.
Full exchange warehouses, quiet Ivorian farms
US$4,871 works out to roughly Rp87.97 million a ton at Bank Indonesia’s JISDOR rate. The thin Ivory Coast shipments still keep the price from falling further, according to the same source.
The supply outlook is shadowed by weather. Industry sources quoted by Reuters expect Ivory Coast’s 2026/27 mid-crop to fall 42 to 50%, to 300,000 to 350,000 tons. Late and uneven rain in October, linked to El Niño, is the risk.
Two forecasts, same direction
StoneX projects 2026/27 world output down 9.6% to 4.74 million tons, with a 494,000 ton surplus flipping to a 64,000 ton deficit. TransGraph Consulting, in a July report quoted by Kontan, expects output down about 5% and prices in a range of US$4,800 to US$6,800 a ton over six months. The two numbers differ, but the direction is the same, and today’s price sits at the low end of TransGraph’s range.
Why Indonesia is exposed
Domestic chocolate-industry demand is about 440,000 to 450,000 tons, while Indonesian cocoa output is projected at around 200,000 tons in 2026/27. That means about half of the raw material is imported, mainly from Ivory Coast, Ghana, and Ecuador, according to TransGraph via Kontan. Yields on Indonesian farms are about 0.14 tons per hectare, against roughly 0.46 in Ghana.
The government set the November 2026 reference price for cocoa beans at US$5,613.60 a ton, down 7.33% from the previous period, under Trade Minister Decree No. 2064/2026 (Katadata, 2 November). That reference price is the basis for the export duty on cocoa beans, which is 7.5% this November.
Chocolate on the shelf won’t necessarily follow
This is our own reasoning, with no source. The price of beans on the exchange and the price of a chocolate bar are separated by several stages, so a drop on the exchange doesn’t automatically reach the shelf. We haven’t found data on retail chocolate prices in Indonesia.
When the headline says “cocoa prices plunge”
This is our own suggestion. Check two things. Whose price is being quoted, the New York exchange, the government’s reference price, or the farm-gate price? And the date, because cocoa can move almost 5% in a single day.
Sources
- Harga Kakao Hari Ini 11 November 2026, Reku, 11 November 2026
- El Nino Berpotensi Pangkas Produksi Kakao hingga 5%, Indonesia Masih Bergantung Impor, Kontan, 30 July 2026
- Harga Acuan CPO dan Kakao Turun, Pemerintah Tetapkan Bea Keluar US$ 124, Katadata, 2 November 2026