Who actually pays America's import tariffs?
Filed By irfolks
Economics Desk4 min read
Since 24 July 2026, goods made in Indonesia entering the United States face an extra 10% tariff. Who ends up paying?
American shoppers pay part of it through higher prices. The New York Fed estimates that each one-point rise in the average tariff pushes consumer goods prices up about 0.25% within a year.
The legal basis changed, the tariff stayed
On 20 February 2026, the US Supreme Court ruled that the emergency-powers law President Trump had used for his tariffs (IEEPA) doesn’t allow them. The government immediately put in a stand-in 10% tariff, limited to 150 days and running until 24 July 2026.
When that ran out, another legal route took over. From 24 July, the US applies Section 301, a trade law, after an investigation into forced labor in 60 economies. The rate is 10% or 12.5%, depending on what each country has done to ban imports made with forced labor. Indonesia is in the 10% group. Tariffs on steel, aluminum, and cars (Section 232, 25% to 50%) run separately and don’t stack with the new one.
Prices rose on the shelf, and lower-income families feel it most
Two studies from the US central bank system answer who pays.
The first is from the New York Fed, published 6 October 2026. Two-thirds of the effect comes straight from higher prices of imported goods, which rose almost one-for-one with the tariff in the first month. The other third comes from American-made goods, whose prices adjust over six to twelve months. Tariffs added 2.9 percentage points to goods inflation, peaking in February 2026. The effect on the goods price level peaked near 3% then, and is expected to ease to about 2% by August.
The second is from the Federal Reserve Board, revised in August 2026. The burden of tariffs falls harder on lower-income families. Spending on affected goods drops about three times as much as prices rise, and the drop is concentrated in non-essential goods. Households that worry about the economy shift their spending toward necessities and trade down to cheaper versions.
For factories in Indonesia, the number isn’t final
A 10% tariff is only part of the story. Indonesia’s government expects the final rate to be around 18%. That’s what Susiwijono Moegiarso, secretary of the Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs, said on 6 June 2026: 10% from the forced-labor investigation, plus a second piece about excess industrial capacity whose rate hadn’t been set yet. The final number still has to go through US legal procedures and public comment.
There’s some good news. Products already under Section 232 tariffs, certain raw materials, and goods the US can’t make in sufficient quantity are exempt from that 10%.
As of writing, we couldn’t find a decision on the second piece. We also couldn’t find the outcome of the tariff-rate quotas, which set volumes of Indonesian products allowed in at a lower rate and which the US said it would establish by 1 September 2026.
The effect reaches Indonesia by a detour
This part is our own reasoning and has no source behind it. If American shoppers hold back on non-essential goods, as the Fed study shows, orders to the factories that make those goods could shrink too. A tariff that keeps changing legal basis, with a number that isn’t final, also makes contract prices hard to work out. We haven’t found Indonesian data showing that has already happened.
Three questions for any tariff headline
A tariff story usually gives one number, like “tariff rises to 10%”. Three questions make that number more useful. This is our own advice.
First, who pays? By law the importer pays the tariff, but the cost gets split among shoppers, retailers, and the people who make the goods, and the split differs for every product. Second, which goods are hit? Check the exemptions, because some goods are free of it or carry a different rate. Third, until when? A temporary tariff can change legal basis, as in the story above, so look at the effective date.
A US import tariff looks far away. Its cost still shows up in shelf prices and in factory orders.
Sources
- How Fast Do Tariffs Pass Through into Consumer Prices?, Liberty Street Economics, Federal Reserve Bank of New York, 6 October 2026
- Paying More and Buying Less: 2025 Tariffs and U.S. Household Spending, Federal Reserve Board, revised August 2026
- Emerging Tariff Framework Post Section 122, Thompson Coburn, July 2026
- U.S. Hits Indonesia with 10% Forced-Labor Tariff in 60-Economy Section 301 Blitz, Investortrust, 24 July 2026
- Indonesia Expects 18 Percent U.S. Tariff as Trade Probe Nears Conclusion, RRI, 6 June 2026